Skip to content
personpersonEddie VarnesEddie VarnesInvestigator for Donna Adelson's former defense team who conducted an unrecorded August 2024 jail interview with Patricia Byrd.← All People
Witness

Eddie Varnes

Courtroom still of Eddie Varnes.

Investigator for Donna Adelson's former defense team who conducted an unrecorded August 2024 jail interview with Patricia Byrd.

61 lines·3 proceedings

About

Eddie Varnes, a private investigator, testified for the defense on Day 7 about an August 2024 jail interview with Patricia Byrd concerning information she said she had received about statements by Katherine Magbanua. Varnes testified that Byrd did not tell him Donna Adelson had offered compensation, confessed, or directed Byrd's account.

Varnes said the interview was not recorded at the instruction of prior defense counsel. He also testified that Byrd expected a plea offer from the State in her own case.

On cross-examination, the State questioned Varnes about the lack of a recording, his immediate report to prior counsel, his decision not to seek a recorded follow-up, and his paid engagement. On redirect, Varnes reaffirmed that he was recounting what Byrd had told him. The court sustained a State objection to a question about his experience as improper bolstering.

Trial Record (3)

DADonna AdelsonAug 22, 2025 – Sep 4, 2025Called by defense

Eddie Varnes testified for the defense on Day 7 about an unrecorded jail interview with Patricia Byrd. The State questioned the lack of a recording and his paid engagement, and he reaffirmed his account on redirect.

Day 7

DirectEddie Varnes - DirectEddie VarnesJoshua D. Zelman2highlights36lines spoken

Summary

Defense investigator Eddie Varnes described an unrecorded 2024 jail interview with Patricia Byrd and testified that she did not attribute offers, a confession, or instructions to Donna Adelson.

Highlights (2)

testimony highlightVarnes described meeting Patricia Byrd at the Leon County Jail on August 30, 2024 after defense counsel told him she might have information about the case; he said Byrd reported information about what Katie Magbanua had said while they were incarcerated together.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“I was instructed by prior defense counsel to not record the interview.”— Eddie VarnesDocuments the absence of a recording of the defense investigator's interview with Byrd.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
CrossEddie Varnes - CrossEddie VarnesSarah Kathryn Dugan2highlights20lines spoken

Summary

The State examined why Eddie Varnes's interview with Patricia Byrd was unrecorded and what follow-up he took afterward.

Highlights (2)

RedirectEddie Varnes - RedirectEddie VarnesJoshua D. Zelman2highlights5lines spoken

Summary

Varnes reaffirmed his account of Patricia Byrd's statements and said he understood she had been listed as a defense witness by prior counsel.

Highlights (2)