Skip to content
Dan Markel Case Archive

Garcia–Magbanua

Joint trial of Sigfredo Garcia and Katherine Magbanua for the 2014 murder-for-hire of Dan Markel. Prosecutors alleged Garcia was one of the shooters and Magbanua was the intermediary between the hitmen and Charlie Adelson.

Date
September 26 - October 11, 2019
Judge
James C. Hankinson
Court
Leon County Circuit Court, Second Judicial Circuit, Tallahassee, Florida

Sigfredo Garcia

Convicted
Charges (3)
Count 1First-degree murderGuilty
Count 2Conspiracy to commit first-degree murderGuilty
Count 3Solicitation to commit first-degree murderNot guilty

Katherine Magbanua

Mistrial on all counts
Charges (3)
Count 1First-degree murderMistrial
Count 2Conspiracy to commit first-degree murderMistrial
Count 3Solicitation to commit first-degree murderMistrial
11Trial Days
43Witnesses
278Proceedings
41Sidebars
40,356Lines

September 2019

October 2019

TueOct 17:04:08
WedOct 27:22:40
ThuOct 37:26:01
FriOct 47:27:46
MonOct 78:00:57
TueOct 88:10:44
WedOct 96:58:26
ThuOct 1011:23:46
Day 10Closing Arguments, Final Instructions, and Jury Deliberations→

Closing arguments presented competing accounts of the alleged plot before final instructions and jury deliberations.

FriOct 116:47:11
Day 11Garcia Verdicts and Magbanua Mistrial→

The jury returned guilty verdicts against Sigfredo Garcia on first-degree murder and conspiracy charges, with all 12 jurors confirming the verdict. The court declared a mistrial in Katherine Magbanua's case after the jury reported no unanimous decision on any charge.