Skip to content
Garcia–Magbanuatrial-daytrial-dayGeorgia CapplemanAnna NorrisChristopher DeCosteSaam ZangenehBill BrannonChristopher CorbittThomas BalboniLen HarveyJeffrey LacasseSteven LutesLuis Riveradirectcrossjury_questionredirectDay 3 - October 1, 2019Fingerprint, surveillance, crime-scene, phone-record, and Rivera testimony were presented as the court addressed evidentiary issues.
← Day 2Garcia–MagbanuaDay 4 →

Day 3 - October 1, 2019

Fingerprint and Phone Evidence, Lacasse and Rivera Testimony

Judge James C. Hankinson
31Proceedings
7Pages
7Witnesses
4,631Lines
6Sidebars
Day 3 of 11
Appearing:

Fingerprint, surveillance, crime-scene, phone-record, and Rivera testimony were presented as the court addressed evidentiary issues.

Full day summary

The court denied requests to strike part of Mr. Yao's testimony or exclude Officer Bill Brannon after his brief courtroom presence, while limiting Brannon from testifying about matters related to Yao's testimony. Thomas Balboni testified that a right-thumb print on a pawn form matched Sigfredo Garcia's known print. The court admitted original Premier Health and Fitness surveillance footage, along with Pembroke Pines ATM footage and still images. Officer Brannon described the Trescott Drive scene and a van that approached the perimeter and turned away. On cross-examination, he acknowledged that he could not identify its driver, confirm the van, or know why it turned around. Jeffrey Lacasse testified about statements he attributed to Wendi Adelson concerning Charlie Adelson and the relocation dispute; on cross-examination, he acknowledged limits in his recollection and that he did not report the statement to law enforcement before the killing. Christopher Corbitt described phone and tower-dump records, including reports identifying Magbanua's number as Garcia's most frequent contact during the May-to-July 2014 period. He emphasized that historical cell-site analysis provides a general area, not a precise handset location. Luis Rivera then testified under a cooperation agreement that Garcia recruited him for a Tallahassee job, that Rivera drove a rented Prius, and that he saw Garcia shoot Dan Markel. Rivera also described alleged calls and payment discussions involving Katie. Garcia's counsel began cross-examination concerning Rivera's Latin Kings affiliation, past criminal conduct, prior statements, and his account of the trips and payment.

Video thumbnail7:04:08
Watch →

1. Privilege and Sequestration Rulings; Thomas Balboni — Direct/Cross

The court addressed Rivera-attorney privilege and Brannon sequestration issues before Thomas Balboni testified that a pawn-form thumbprint matched Sigfredo Garcia's right thumbprint.

Procedural
Rivera-Attorney Privilege and Brannon Sequestration Issues
88 lines

The court reserved the Rivera-attorney privilege dispute and denied defense sequestration requests concerning Officer Brannon.

Direct
Thomas Balboni - Direct Thomas Balboni Georgia Cappleman
81 lines

Fingerprint examiner Thomas Balboni testified that Garcia’s known right thumbprint matched the print on a pawn ticket listed in Garcia’s name.

Cross
Thomas Balboni - Cross Thomas Balboni Saam Zangeneh
65 lines

Balboni confirmed that his fingerprint work on the 2013 Miami pawn form was limited and that he did not pursue related records or surveillance.

Cross
Thomas Balboni - Cross Thomas Balboni Christopher DeCoste
13 lines

Balboni confirmed the pawn form fingerprint matched Garcia's right thumbprint and did not include Magbanua's fingerprints.

Jury Questions
Thomas Balboni - Juror Questions Thomas Balboni James C. Hankinson
29 lines

Balboni answered juror questions about the date Garcia's fingerprints were taken and fingerprint longevity.

2. Len Harvey — Direct/Cross (Recall)

Len Harvey authenticated original Premier Health surveillance footage, then described camera coverage, blind spots, and facility security practices.

Direct
Len Harvey - Direct Len Harvey Georgia Cappleman
52 lines

Harvey authenticated the complete original surveillance footage, and the court admitted State's Exhibit 177 after the defense withdrew its objection.

Cross
Len Harvey - Cross Len Harvey Saam Zangeneh
65 lines

Harvey described limits in his surveillance review and camera coverage, and did not recall video of Garcia leaving the Prius.

Jury Questions
Len Harvey - Juror Questions Len Harvey James C. Hankinson
55 lines

Harvey explained the camera labels and business layout, then answered a brief follow-up about monitoring and parking-lot staffing.

3. Bill Brannon — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Officer Bill Brannon described the crime scene and an unidentified Honda Odyssey that approached the perimeter; questioning focused on the limits of his observations and when he learned Ms. Adelson's vehicle color.

Direct
Bill Brannon - Direct Bill Brannon Georgia Cappleman
100 lines

Officer Brannon described the crime scene and a Honda Odyssey van that approached the perimeter, turned around, and left.

Cross
Bill Brannon - Cross Bill Brannon Saam Zangeneh
120 lines

Brannon described limited vehicle documentation at the perimeter and said he reported, but did not stop, a vehicle matching a description he had received.

Cross
Bill Brannon - Cross Bill Brannon Christopher DeCoste
104 lines

Brannon acknowledged limits in identifying the van and its occupant; the judge later instructed jurors not to discredit witnesses for speaking with attorneys.

Redirect
Bill Brannon - Redirect Bill Brannon Georgia Cappleman
13 lines

Brannon clarified the emergency-vehicle locations and said he promptly notified another officer about the vehicle he observed.

Jury Questions
Bill Brannon - Juror Questions Bill Brannon James C. Hankinson
21 lines

Brannon said he learned Ms. Adelson's vehicle color before seeing the van, but could not recall exactly when.

Jury Questions
Bill Brannon - Juror Question Follow-up by Magbanua Bill Brannon Christopher DeCoste
15 lines

Brannon said he knew Ms. Adelson's vehicle color before seeing the van and could not say when his report was reviewed.

Jury Questions
Bill Brannon - Juror Questions (Resumed) Bill Brannon James C. Hankinson
15 lines

Officer Bill Brannon was excused, and the court took a brief recess before the next witness.

4. Jeffrey Lacasse — Direct/Cross

Jeffrey Lacasse completed testimony about his former relationship with Wendi Adelson, his reported account of comments concerning the custody dispute and Charlie Adelson, and his travel at the time of the homicide.

Direct
Jeffrey Lacasse - Direct Jeffrey Lacasse Georgia Cappleman
106 lines

Lacasse testified about statements he attributed to Ms. Adelson concerning the relocation dispute, a celebration dinner, and his travel at the time of the homicide.

Cross
Jeffrey Lacasse - Cross Jeffrey Lacasse Saam Zangeneh
314 lines

Lacasse was questioned about his travel timing, relationship with Wendi Adelson, and his reporting of a statement he attributed to her.

Cross
Jeffrey Lacasse - Cross Jeffrey Lacasse Christopher DeCoste
104 lines

Lacasse described how investigators verified his Tennessee whereabouts and acknowledged limits on his knowledge of Wendi Adelson's schedule and the reported statement's scope.

Redirect
Jeffrey Lacasse - Redirect Jeffrey Lacasse Georgia Cappleman
8 lines

Lacasse said he last saw Wendi Adelson on July 14, 2014 and that they never resumed their relationship.

Jury Questions
Jeffrey Lacasse - Juror Questions Jeffrey Lacasse James C. Hankinson
65 lines

The court excluded one proposed juror question, and Lacasse answered brief follow-up questions about email accounts, custody discussions, and his vehicle.

5. Steven Lutes — Direct/Cross

Steven Lutes authenticated admitted Pembroke Pines ATM surveillance video; cross-examination addressed its limits, and the video was published without audio.

Direct
Steven Lutes - Direct Steven Lutes Georgia Cappleman
77 lines

Bank security specialist Steven Lutes authenticated ATM surveillance video and related still images, which the court admitted.

Cross
Steven Lutes - Cross Steven Lutes Saam Zangeneh
152 lines

Lutes said the ATM video showed an apparent transaction but could not identify its type or the vehicle's movements beyond the recorded footage.

6. Christopher Corbitt — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Christopher Corbitt explained the limits of historical cell-site analysis while testifying about phone records, contacts involving Garcia and Magbanua, and a tower near Premier Health and Fitness.

Direct
Christopher Corbitt - Direct Christopher Corbitt Anna Norris
423 lines

Corbitt explained the phone-record and tower-dump analysis that identified Garcia's number and showed Magbanua as his most frequent contact, while stressing that cell-site analysis provides only a general location.

1 sidebar inside this proceeding
  1. Objection to Unreviewed Jury DisplayDefense counsel objected to material proposed for display to the jury because it had not been provided for review.
Cross
Christopher Corbitt - Cross Christopher Corbitt Saam Zangeneh
239 lines

Corbitt acknowledged limits on what cell-phone records could show, while the court restricted questions about another Garcia phone but allowed the defense to recall him later.

1 sidebar inside this proceeding
  1. Cell Data Testimony ScopeThe defense sought to explore an alternative explanation involving phone numbers and cell data beyond the timeframe covered on direct examination.
Cross
Christopher Corbitt - Cross Christopher Corbitt Christopher DeCoste
70 lines

Corbitt agreed that phone-frequency records did not reveal communication content or capture connections outside the available records.

Redirect
Christopher Corbitt - Redirect Christopher Corbitt Anna Norris
22 lines

Corbitt clarified the limits of his investigative role and confirmed Garcia's handset communicated with a T-Mobile tower near Premier Health and Fitness.

sidebar
Juror Questions About Phone Evidence Christopher Corbitt James C. Hankinson
31 lines

Counsel discussed objections to juror questions about a phone number on a demonstrative and other phone activity that could contact a cell tower.

Jury Questions
Christopher Corbitt - Juror Questions Christopher Corbitt James C. Hankinson
11 lines

Corbitt said data use can cause tower contact, but not every carrier's records show that activity.

7. Rivera Hearsay and Disclosure Motions; Luis Rivera — Direct/Cross

Luis Rivera testified under a cooperation agreement that Garcia recruited him for a Tallahassee job and that Rivera drove while Garcia shot Dan Markel; cross-examination focused on Rivera's criminal history, cooperation, prior statements, and alleged inconsistencies.

Procedural
Rivera Hearsay and Disclosure Motions
23 lines

Defense counsel raised anticipated hearsay and disclosure issues before Luis Rivera testified; the State reported no new disclosure items.

Direct
Luis Rivera - Direct Luis Rivera Georgia Cappleman
1235 lines

Rivera testified that Garcia recruited him, shot Dan Markel, and later discussed payment with Katie; the court also reserved a discovery issue over a voice-identification exhibit.

1 sidebar inside this proceeding
  1. Voice Identification and Discovery DisputeCounsel disputed the foundation for voice identification and whether a highlighted phone-call summary had been provided in discovery.
Cross
Luis Rivera - Cross Luis Rivera Saam Zangeneh
915 lines

Garcia's counsel tested Rivera's gang connections, criminal history, prior statements, and recollection of the Tallahassee trips; the court set limits on several lines of questioning.

2 sidebars inside this proceeding
  1. Limits on Latin King QuestioningThe sidebar addressed limits on questioning about Rivera's Latin King involvement and alleged connections to other members.
  2. Drug-Dealing Question ScopeAt sidebar, counsel discussed whether a question about prior drug dealing could be supported by conduct addressed in the witness's factual proffer.
← Day 2Garcia–MagbanuaDay 4 →