Skip to content
Charlie Adelsontrial-daytrial-dayGeorgia CapplemanDan RashbaumBill BrannonWendi AdelsonRyan FitzpatrickJeffrey LacasseLuis RiveraJune UmchindaStephen WebstercrossredirectdirectrecrossDay 2 - October 27, 2023Wendi Adelson completed her testimony, Jeffrey Lacasse returned to testify about disputed statements, and Luis Rivera described the killing.
← Day 1Charlie AdelsonDay 3 →

Day 2 - October 27, 2023

Wendi Adelson Recall, Lacasse Testimony, and Rivera's Account

Judge Stephen S. Everett
32Proceedings
9Pages
7Witnesses
3,853Lines
Day 2 of 8
Appearing:

Wendi Adelson completed her testimony, Jeffrey Lacasse returned to testify about disputed statements, and Luis Rivera described the killing.

Full day summary

Wendi Adelson completed her testimony after cross-examination and redirect addressing her 2014 Tallahassee plans, relocation dispute, and police interview. The court excluded proposed impeachment through Jeffrey Lacasse on two subjects on fundamental-fairness grounds, then recalled Wendi Adelson, who denied telling Lacasse that Charlie Adelson had explored hiring a hitman or called a post-homicide dinner a celebration dinner. After her recall testimony, Lacasse testified to his account of those statements; defense questioning addressed the timing of his police reports and notes he later destroyed. Stephen Webster described Dan Markel's family-law dispute and June Umchinda and Ryan Fitzpatrick testified about later interactions with Charlie Adelson. Luis Rivera then testified that Garcia brought him a job to kill Dan Markel, described surveillance trips and a $100,000 payment arrangement, and said Garcia shot Markel after Rivera drove into the driveway.

Video thumbnail8:15:05
Watch →

1. Wendi Adelson — Cross/Redirect

Wendi Adelson's cross-examination continued, followed by redirect testimony and a recess discussion of limits on anticipated testimony from Luis Rivera and Jeffrey Lacasse.

→
Cross
Wendi Adelson - Cross (Part 2) Wendi Adelson Dan Rashbaum
687 lines

Wendi Adelson testified about her Tallahassee plans, July 2014 activities, police cooperation, and relationship with Jeffrey Lacasse as the defense challenged a relocation-based motive.

Redirect
Wendi Adelson - Redirect Wendi Adelson Georgia Cappleman
228 lines

Wendi Adelson explained her move from Tallahassee, addressed the indictment and recorded calls, and responded to questions about family access and the defense theory; the court gave two limiting instructions.

Procedural
Recess and Sidebar Preview — Next Two Witnesses
40 lines

The court set proffer and scope limits for anticipated Rivera testimony, confirmed a hearsay limitation for Mr. Lacasse, and clarified a prior witness could not opine on constitutional law.

2. Bill Brannon — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Officer Bill Brannon described the Trescott Drive perimeter and a minivan that approached the roadblock before turning away.

→
Direct
Bill Brannon - Direct Bill Brannon Georgia Cappleman
125 lines

Officer Bill Brannon described securing the Trescott Drive scene and observing a Honda Odyssey-type vehicle approach the roadblock, turn around, and leave.

Cross
Bill Brannon - Cross Bill Brannon Dan Rashbaum
25 lines

Brannon qualified his estimates about the perimeter and vehicle timing and said he was unfamiliar with cell-phone data.

Redirect
Bill Brannon - Redirect Bill Brannon Georgia Cappleman
23 lines

Brannon confirmed the roadblock markings and said he could see the law-enforcement activity from his perspective.

3. Jeffrey Lacasse — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Jeffrey Lacasse's testimony continued, followed by an outside-the-jury hearing that temporarily excluded proposed impeachment evidence concerning an alleged statement by Wendi Adelson.

→
Direct
Jeffrey Lacasse - Direct Jeffrey Lacasse Georgia Cappleman
228 lines

Jeffrey Lacasse described Wendi Adelson's relocation-related distress, a purported statement by Charles Adelson about criminal connections, and June–July 2014 events before the jury was excused over a disputed line of testimony.

Procedural
Motion in Limine: Exclusion of Lacasse Proffer on Wendi Adelson's Alleged Hitman Statement — Ruled Out on Fairness Grounds Jeffrey Lacasse
152 lines

The court barred proposed impeachment of Wendi Adelson through Jeffrey Lacasse on fairness grounds, heard a proffer outside the jury's presence, and temporarily applied the same ruling to the celebration-dinner issue.

Cross
Jeffrey Lacasse - Cross Jeffrey Lacasse Dan Rashbaum
132 lines

Defense counsel challenged Jeffrey Lacasse's memory, the timing of his police report, his cordial text to Charlie Adelson, and the basis for his account of Wendi Adelson's distress.

Redirect
Jeffrey Lacasse - Redirect Jeffrey Lacasse Georgia Cappleman
11 lines

Jeffrey Lacasse said he did not know of the alleged conspiracy during his earlier interactions with the defendant and Katherine Magbanua.

4. Stephen Webster — Direct/Cross

Stephen Webster, Dan Markel's family-law attorney, testified about Markel's call on the morning of the murder and continuing disputes involving the children, alleged parental alienation, and property.

→
Procedural
Lunch Recess
22 lines

The court recessed for lunch, reminded defense counsel to keep future proffers from being overheard, and then resumed the State's case.

Direct
Stephen Webster - Direct Stephen Webster Georgia Cappleman
85 lines

Dan Markel's attorney described ongoing family-court conflict, rejected a relocation-payoff scenario, and said Markel was not planning to relocate.

Cross
Stephen Webster - Cross Stephen Webster Dan Rashbaum
36 lines

Defense briefly questioned Stephen Webster about his family-law experience and representation of Professor Markel.

Procedural
Afternoon Transition — Witness Located, Jury Projector Glare Note
40 lines

5. June Umchinda — Direct/Cross/Redirect

June Umchinda's testimony addressed her observations of Charlie Adelson's behavior and residence, with questioning about when those observations occurred.

→
Direct
June Umchinda - Direct June Umchinda Georgia Cappleman
395 lines

June Umchinda described her relationship with Charlie Adelson, her observations after the investigation became known to her, and prior statements the prosecutor used to question her current account.

Cross
June Umchinda - Cross June Umchinda Dan Rashbaum
173 lines

Defense challenged the timing and scope of June Umchinda's observations, while the court excluded a proposed account of Charlie Adelson's response as self-serving hearsay.

Redirect
June Umchinda - Redirect June Umchinda Georgia Cappleman
34 lines

June Umchinda addressed earlier statements about Charlie's behavior and his claimed assistance to Katherine Magbanua.

7. Jeffrey Lacasse — Direct/Cross/Redirect/Recross (Recall)

Jeffrey Lacasse completed his recalled testimony as counsel examined his account of alleged hitman-related statements, his delayed reports to police, and notes he later destroyed.

→
Direct
Jeffrey Lacasse - Direct (Recall) Jeffrey Lacasse Georgia Cappleman
77 lines

Jeffrey Lacasse recounted a reported hitman statement, questions about his planned trip, and evidence he said placed him in Tennessee at the time of the homicide.

Cross
Jeffrey Lacasse - Cross Jeffrey Lacasse Dan Rashbaum
114 lines

Defense challenged the timing and reliability of Jeffrey Lacasse's reported statements; Lacasse maintained his account and explained his delayed police report.

Redirect
Jeffrey Lacasse - Redirect Jeffrey Lacasse Georgia Cappleman
32 lines

Lacasse clarified his recollection and recordkeeping, then explained why he did not report an alleged hitman-related statement before the murder.

Procedural
Post-Lacasse Sidebar — Notes Inquiry and Break
45 lines
Recross
Jeffrey Lacasse - Recross Jeffrey Lacasse Dan Rashbaum
17 lines

Lacasse said he destroyed notes used to guide investigator interviews, and the defense emphasized that the notes could not be reviewed.

Redirect
Jeffrey Lacasse - Redirect (2nd) Jeffrey Lacasse Georgia Cappleman
10 lines

Lacasse said his personal notes were voluntary organizational aids and that their contents were included in the provided interviews.

8. Ryan Fitzpatrick — Direct/Cross

Ryan Fitzpatrick's direct and cross-examination covered his relationship with Charlie Adelson, alleged remarks and behavior, and later disputes between the two. Outside the jury's presence, the court addressed a proffer and cross-examination scheduling for Luis Rivera.

→
Direct
Ryan Fitzpatrick - Direct Ryan Fitzpatrick Georgia Cappleman
157 lines

Former friend Ryan Fitzpatrick testified about Charlie Adelson's family relationships, cash handling, post-2016-arrest demeanor, and alleged disclosures, while acknowledging a later personal falling out and limits on his memory.

Cross
Ryan Fitzpatrick - Cross Ryan Fitzpatrick Dan Rashbaum
102 lines

Ryan Fitzpatrick acknowledged hostile messages and recent social-media posts about Charlie as the defense questioned his motives and whether public attention could explain the behavior he observed after Katie's arrest.

Procedural
Sidebar Transition — Witness Logistics and Cross-Examination Scheduling
29 lines

The court arranged a defense proffer and discussed timing for Rivera's testimony and possible cross-examination.

← Day 1Charlie AdelsonDay 3 →